Senate passes important reforms while enabling net-zero agenda

Photo Credit: Getty

There is a lot to be happy about given that the Senate passed its permitting bill last night, by a vote of 62-33.

Many of the permitting reforms in the bill have been high on CEI’s list and were reforms this author has been working on for a long time, especially those related to the Clean Water Act (CWA). In many ways, the bill mirrors important principles CEI has argued should inform any permitting bill, including the need to reform numerous statutes.

This bill provides important and meaningful reforms to numerous laws. For example, the bill establishes a 150-day statute of limitations for National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA) challenges. Also, when there is a flaw in a NEPA analysis, a court may no longer void the permitting decision. It can only direct an agency to fix the analysis. 

There are important reforms to the CWA, such as prohibiting the Environmental Protection Agency from preemptively or retroactively vetoing lawfully issued US Army Corps of Engineers Section 404 dredge and fill permits. There are other reforms too, such as to the National Historic Preservation Act.

These reforms shouldn’t be minimized. Our country is in desperate need of permitting reform and the bill delivers in many ways.

But it comes at a major cost, which is primarily related to the electric transmission title of the bill. Just as the good reforms shouldn’t be minimized, nor should the harmful effects of the transmission title.

Enabling net zero

The legislation radically changes electric transmission policy in two important aspects. First, it allows transmission developers to bypass the states and force them to accept long-range transmission lines that cross their states, including by the use of federal eminent domain. Second, it codifies a process to socialize the enormous costs of transmission lines away from renewable developers and states with renewable goals that want the lines, to everyday Americans. This title of the bill not only throws principles of federalism out the window but will also make it harder for states to protect their citizens’ property and pocketbooks.

Make no mistake, the permitting bill will enable the left’s net-zero agenda and its push to shift electricity generation to wind and solar. As the mantra goes, there is no transition without transmission. The bill will help give the left its electricity transition and make Americans pay for it. The primary reason (if not sole reason) that many on the left support the bill is because of the transmission title. This is a big win for them, getting wind and solar projects onto the grid and giving them access to electric markets regardless of the merits of such projects. And the bill doesn’t provide adequate protection to ensure reliability and affordability, as former Federal Energy Regulatory Commission Chairman Mark Christie has pointed out.

One would think that there would be ways to improve the bill in the House. But that isn’t looking promising. There is a good chance there will be no amendments considered in the House and the options for House members will be to just pass the Senate bill as-is or reject it.  

Let’s hope that isn’t how it plays out.

There needs to at least be some effort to amend the bill to mitigate the negative effects of the transmission title.

Next steps for conservatives if the bill becomes law

If the bill does pass and become law as-is, conservatives can be happy about the many good reforms in the bill.

But they will also need to fight against wind and solar subsidies even more than before. The Democrats have already been saying they want to bring back at least some Inflation Reduction Act subsidies.

There is much talk about not picking winners and losers in energy; the permitting bill on the surface does appear to abide by this principle. But the transmission title itself is primarily for the benefit of wind and solar.

And as I have argued, permitting reform doesn’t exist in a vacuum. The left will pick winners and losers, as they did in the Inflation Reduction Act, through spending measures, such as wind and solar subsidies.

Then there will be regulations to punish reliable electricity (e.g., coal and natural gas) with the goal of transitioning the grid to wind and solar.

A future Democrat administration will use statutes to impose regulatory requirements that will directly or in effect lead to shutting down coal and natural gas plants and shifting electricity to wind and solar. That is exactly what the Obama and Biden administrations did with their greenhouse gas regulations for power plants under the Clean Air Act.

Conservatives and others concerned about reliable and affordable energy will need to be focused on stopping such spending and regulatory mischief. They would have needed to anyway, but if the permitting bill becomes law as-is, it will be even more important.