Stop modernizing infrastructure

Photo Credit: Getty

The consensus following the Federal Aviation Administration’s (FAA) nationwide ground stop on November 13 was preordained: give the FAA money to build tomorrow’s air traffic bottlenecks and make tomorrow’s systems obsolete before they’re even built.

The necessary privatization case has long been made (by experts like Robert Poole of the Reason Foundation and Chris Edwards at the Cato Institute) as a remedy for chronic underinvestment in equipment and technology. But, as expected, that case is being ignored in favor of progressive administrative management masquerading as technological modernization.

It’s not that “you will have more of these [ground stops]…unless the American people and the Congress tell us to build,” as Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy warned. It’s closer to the opposite: you’ll have more systemic failures precisely because we keep building and managing infrastructure through the prevailing top-down model of centralized planning, procurement, and regulation.

It’s time to consider the lesson fully learned, and to at long last privatize, liberalize, and build redundancy into old and new networks across all infrastructure sectors, not just the FAA.

What passes for modernization is too often merely sustainment of a political process engineered to retain centralized government management of our most vital infrastructures, from underground lead pipes to airspace; and to shield them from the competitive processes that would actually be capable of continually expanding, renewing, and protecting them.

We don’t periodically lament the disinvestment and crumbling of privately developed commercial infrastructure like big-box retailers, fast-food chains, technology companies, or gas station networks. These all constitute vital infrastructure too. But they continually churn, perpetually renewing themselves. Even bankruptcy doesn’t demolish the underlying infrastructure or extinguish the market process that replaces and improves what came before. As Jay Leno used to say in the old Doritos commercials, “Crunch all you want. We’ll make more.”

Central administration distorts the nation’s great infrastructure, from electrical systems to the networks carrying people, goods, information, water, and energy. The infrastructures we most depend on are precisely the systems that government, as an institution, is inherently incapable of maintaining in a hyperconnected economy.

The modernization trap

Why is supposedly indispensable public infrastructure so frequently in need of federal rescue?

The problem with America’s infrastructure is not that it’s decades old. Its age is a manifestation of infrastructure organized, regulated, financed, and ultimately constrained by government. Political appropriations and regulatory processes are poor substitutes for continuous competitive pressure. Politicians show up for ribbon-cuttings but disappear when maintenance is required.

Genuine modernization would require ending government’s longstanding dominance over infrastructure and allowing wealth-creating enterprises far from Washington to develop and maintain it.

Centralization creates systemic vulnerability

The FAA episode illustrates how modern infrastructure networks are complicated, interdependent arrangements. An upgrade in one component can create problems elsewhere, particularly when legacy systems, new technologies, and multiple institutional authorities must operate together. Similar concerns apply to electricity grids, telecommunications, data centers, the emerging infrastructure of artificial intelligence, and much more. Centralized planning and procurement tend to engineer fragility into all of them, when they should be evolving through decentralized, mutually reinforcing experimentation.

The more functions are integrated into centralized architectures without adequate redundancy or the ability to isolate compromised components and exclude malicious actors, the greater the consequences when those architectures fail or are compromised. So, while the FAA’s proposed $50 billion infusion might deliver some technological progress, without corresponding institutional progress it amounts to little more than putting the system on a runway to nowhere.

‘Government steering while the market rows’

Washington treats infrastructure as a collection of discrete government projects rather than an evolving ecosystem of assets and business arrangements. Recent infrastructure legislation has bundled roads, bridges, broadband, electricity, charging stations, research, manufacturing, and attendant social programs under the infrastructure label. Smart cities add another dimension: interconnected sensors, cameras, databases, utilities, transportation systems, and automated management platforms.

Politicians pick favorites from each of these through subsidies and public-private partnerships, then layer regulations atop them. The result is disproportionate government influence over private enterprise, an entanglement that becomes increasingly difficult to unwind. The FAA episode demonstrates this problem as a microcosm.

Done right, though, tomorrow’s infrastructures are unlikely to resemble the categories policymakers recognize today. Transportation, communications, electricity, water, data networks, and more can overlap and reinforce one another through bottom-up rights-of-way evolution, user ownership, and innovative combinations of competing and cooperating networks. Data centers and AI, for example, depend on interlocking infrastructure: power, communications, computing capacity, cooling, land, and capital.

The potential for new combinations is enormous, but the government-funding mentality, regulatory silos, exclusive franchises, permitting restrictions, and antitrust interventions impede the entrepreneurial experimentation necessary to produce them. Every politically directed malinvestment displaces alternatives that consumers, entrepreneurs, and investors might otherwise have pursued, potentially amounting to hundreds of billions, even trillions, in unseen distortions and uncreated wealth.

Resilience requires decentralization

The FAA and the alphabet soup of other federal agencies fail to recognize that resilience depends on more than the sophistication of a central system. Whether we have new fiber or old copper is beside the point.

Competing and cooperating networks, alternative supply sources, decentralized decision-making, and the ability to adapt without waiting for Washington are all essential. A genuine infrastructure agenda would therefore look very different from yet another spending package.

These are pro-infrastructure measures in the most consequential sense: allowing more infrastructure to be created, maintained, and constantly improved without its condition becoming a matter of national news.

Stop building tomorrow’s bottlenecks

There is a persistent Washington conceit that every emerging technology or complex social need calls for a national plan or government-directed development. We have seen it with highways, energy, broadband, smart cities, AI, and even tap water. The current enthusiasm for federal and state involvement in data centers repeats the pattern. Addressing this requires a policy of no free rides: no forced access to neighboring jurisdictions’ networks or resources, and no political commandeering of infrastructure whose development and costs properly belong to its owners and users.

Government can help establish the legal framework for property, contracts, and the protection of rights. It can remove barriers to enterprise but must not decide what the next generation of infrastructure should look like, nor finance and manage it.

The FAA stoppage is a reminder that indispensable systems are the very ones we can least afford to make dependent on institutional arrangements that resist adaptation. Infrastructure that constantly evolves never needs modernization. If you hear that term, it means someone has been gumming up the gears with appropriations, regulation, centralized design, and politics, and intends to do it again.

The great private infrastructure wealth of the future has yet to be created. If Washington dominates, it has yet to be destroyed. When it comes to capitalism and production on the largest scales achievable by mankind, government cannot modernize at all. It can only antiquate.

For more, see:

“What To Do Instead Of The America COMPETES Act,” Forbes

“The Growth-By-Deregulation Alternative To Joe Biden’s Cyclopean American Jobs Plan,” Forbes

“The Little Red Hen goes digital: No data centers, no internet,” Competitive Enterprise Institute

“A Constitutional Amendment Banning, Subsidies, Grants and Loan Guarantees,” Forbes