In 1881, America gasped at the assassination of President Garfield – cut down by the bullet of Charles Guiteau, an avid believer in the spoils system of corrupt appointments to government jobs. Garfield had opposed this system, but his death led to – very much intentionally by Guiteau – the rise of Vice President Chester Arthur. In contrast, Arthur had not only supported the spoils system, but owed his entire career in government to the corruption of the New York political machine. No one expected anything different from Arthur’s presidency – except for one person. Julia Sand, a 30-year-old New Yorker of no renown, believed Arthur could become someone better. She took it upon herself to write to Arthur 23 times during his presidency, encouraging him to rise above his corrupt past and do what was best for the nation. Motivated by her words, Arthur threw the corrupt out of his sphere of influence and led Congress to pass Civil Service Reform, ultimately bringing an end to the corrupt bureaucratic system that had made him. The story of Julia Sand shows that every American has a say in creating a government that allows its citizens to flourish.

Click below to read the letters.

Timeline

Letter 1 – Admonishment and encouragement to rise to the occasion

Letter 2 – Sympathy for Arthur’s position

Letter 3 – Caution to stay away from NYC; the soul of the Republican Party; keep Blaine

Letter 4 – Encouraged by Arthur’s actions; names herself Arthur’s dwarf; opinions on Grant

Letter 5 – First expressions of interest in meeting Arthur

Letter 6 – Arthur’s social associations; concern of a 2nd Southern rebellion; Arthur’s Cabinet

Letter 7 – Analyzing Arthur’s new Cabinet; exhorting Arthur to bravery and virtue

Letter 8 – Opposition to the first Chinese Exclusion bill

Letter 9 – Delight at veto of Chinese Exclusion bill; concern over Arthur’s NYC associations

Letter 10 – Advocates against pardoning a guard who attempted to assassinate Charles Guiteau

Letter 11 – Admonishment for signing the second Chinese Exclusion bill

Letter 12 – Faith restored in Arthur; health struggles; sees purpose in influencing Arthur to good

Letter 13 – Gratitude for veto of the River & Harbor bill of 1882; rage at Congress’s override

Letter 14 – Reiterates interest in meeting Arthur; asks him to be cautious with New York politics

Letter 15 – Presents frustration that Arthur has neither visited nor written back

Letter 16 – Reflections on Arthur’s visit

Letter 17 – Advocates against pardons; concern for Arthur’s associations; desires second visit

Letter 18 – Reiterates desire for another visit; recounts meeting Dr. Van Buren

Letter 19 – Requests the opportunity to paint a portrait of Arthur

Letter 20 – Harshness towards Arthur for his associations and failure to communicate with her

Letter 21 – Shares her thoughts on the Republicans’ defeat in the 1882 midterm elections

Letter 22 – Questions Arthur’s resolve on Civil Service Reform; questions if he remembers her

Letter 23 – Mentions a long, serious illness; interest in Arthur’s trip west; soft request for a visit

Discover the incredible true story of Julia Sand and President Chester Arthur. Coming April 2025.

Learn more