New DOL rule says, yes, freelancers are freelancers
Photo Credit: Getty
The Labor Department under President Trump took an important step toward protecting the ability of Americans to have side hustles by issuing a new rule defining “independent contractor” status. The rule states that if a person is an “independent contractor” – that is, a freelancer – then they are in business for themselves.
Specifically, the rule, issued by the Labor Department’s Wage and Hour Division on Thursday, states that two “core factors” will be the main determinants for whether a worker is a freelancer. These are: the degree of control the worker has over the job and the worker’s “opportunity for profit or loss” – i.e., if it is up to the worker whether they profit from the endeavor. A freelancer, for example, might bid too low to win a contract. Taken together, the two factors should provide a commonsense standard for determining when a worker is in business for themselves.
This might all seem to be obvious, but determining when a worker is a freelancer has been a contentious issue for at least a decade. Federal law has no clear definition for an employer-employee relationship. The government has instead relied on a multi-factor test that effectively left the determinations up to regulators.
This matters because a lot of federal laws involving things like overtime and the minimum wage apply only to traditional employment. Should a regulator decide that a person who thought they were working as a freelancer was in fact a traditional employee, then the business would be compelled to treat them as a full-time employee. Many businesses would not be able to afford the worker or manage them, and so this would force them to cut the worker off completely. Most so-called gig economy businesses hire exclusively short-term contractors.
Unions oppose gig economy work because freelancers are much harder to organize. Many workers are freelancers precisely because they want to operate on their own and not be tied down by some other organization’s rules. On top of that, most federal union-related laws, like the National Labor Relations Act, were written with traditional employees in mind and don’t apply to freelancers. Forcing gig economy companies to hire gig workers full-time would make them easier for the unions to organize.
The Labor Department previously used a six-factor test to define traditional employees. Those factors were vaguely defined, however, and none were considered definitive. They included such things as whether the worker primarily relied on freelance work for income, whether they had their own tools and the level of skill required. This gave regulators a lot of leeway to make determinations.
The first Trump administration in 2021 narrowed the factors to two: who has control over the work and “profit or loss” test. The Biden administration, however, undid that rulemaking and even somewhat expanded the definitions of the six factors used, making determinations even more subjective. The current administration’s new rule effectively reinstates the first Trump administration’s rule emphasizing the two main factors, but states that the other factors can also be still considered. The softening of the rule was presumably intended to head off possible legal challenges.
“This rule strikes the right balance by protecting employees who are entitled to the protections of federal wage and hour laws, while also respecting the entrepreneurial spirit of legitimate independent contractors,” said Wage and Hour Administrator Andrew Rogers.
The economy is rapidly changing and so is the definition of work. The laws and regulations have struggled to keep up. Thursday’s rulemaking is a welcome step in that direction.